Vanilla extract lives or dies by the quality of the beans you start with. The right variety, grade, and freshness will determine how deep, sweet, and complex your extract becomes. Here’s how to choose—and use—beans for consistently outstanding results.
What to Look For in Extract Beans
-
Grade: Choose Grade B. They’re drier and more concentrated than Grade A, delivering robust flavor at better value. Grade A also works if that’s what you have—it may infuse a touch faster thanks to higher moisture.
-
Freshness: Pods should bend without snapping and smell clean, sweet, and strong. Avoid brittle or musty beans.
-
Length & Oil: Longer beans (typically 15–20 cm) with a slight sheen often indicate good curing and aromatics.
The Best Varieties for Extract
Vanilla planifolia (Bourbon-style)
Bold, classic vanilla with caramel/cocoa undertones and high vanillin. Excellent all-rounder for baking and beverages.
Great sources: Indonesia and Papua New Guinea (PNG) produce planifolia with depth that stands up in long infusions.
Vanilla tahitensis (Tahitian-style)
Delicate, floral, and fruity (cherry/anise hints). Lower vanillin but high aromatic complexity.
When to use: For lighter, aromatic extracts intended for creams, fruit desserts, and white chocolate work—or blend 70% planifolia with 30% tahitensis for a layered profile.
Proven Ratios (Single vs Double Fold)
-
Single-fold extract: 6–8 whole beans per 1 cup (250 ml) of 35–40% ABV alcohol (vodka, rum, or bourbon).
-
Double-fold extract: 12–16 beans per 1 cup (250 ml) for twice the intensity and less added liquid in recipes.
Step-by-Step: Making Vanilla Extract
-
Split each bean lengthwise to expose the seeds; cut into thirds if needed to submerge.
-
Bottle in a sterilised, tight-sealing glass jar; cover fully with alcohol.
-
Steep in a cool, dark place for 8–12 weeks (single fold) or longer; shake weekly.
-
Mature for 3–6 months for peak complexity. You can top up alcohol as you decant to keep a “perpetual” extract going.
Tips for Maximum Flavor
-
Blend origins/species: Try an Indonesia/PNG planifolia base with a touch of tahitensis for perfume.
-
Mind temperature: Store cool and dark—heat and light flatten aromatics.
-
Use spent beans smartly: After extraction, dry and grind to make vanilla powder or bury in sugar for vanilla sugar.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
-
Too few beans: Leads to thin, one-note extract. Stick to the ratios.
-
Weak alcohol: Below ~35% ABV risks poor extraction and spoilage.
-
Rushing it: Time unlocks complexity; resist using before 8 weeks.
Quick Buying Checklist
-
Grade B (or A if preferred), plump yet slightly drier
-
Clear origin (Indonesia/PNG for robust planifolia; PNG/Tahiti for tahitensis)
-
Vacuum-sealed or freshly packed
-
Length, moisture range, and recent pack date provided
The Bottom Line
For powerhouse, bakery-quality extract, start with Grade B planifolia from Indonesia or PNG, optionally layered with tahitensis for floral lift. Use the right bean load, give it time, and protect it from light and heat—the reward is a concentrated, complex extract that elevates everything from cakes to custards.
Shop premium beans suited to extract making at Banyan Vanilla.
